
By Janice Robinson-Celeste
If grandparents spanking your child is a worry in your family, the words below help you hold the line with love and respect.
Key Takeaways
- Talk to grandparents before the visit, not in the middle of a meltdown.
- Lead with what you share: you both want a respectful, safe, successful child.
- Give grandparents something to do instead, or the old habit will win.
- The American Academy of Pediatrics says spanking increases aggression over time and does not teach self-control.
- If it happens anyway, check on your child first, then talk to the grandparent privately.
It usually happens fast. Your child talks back or throws a cup, and before you can blink, Grandma says it out loud: “That baby needs a good spanking.” You were raised on that same belief. You love her. And you have already decided you are not raising your child that way. Here is how to hold that line without breaking your family apart.
Why Grandma Believes in It
For many of our elders, a whooping was love with a purpose. They grew up in a country that punished Black children harshly for small mistakes, and they believed a hard lesson at home was safer than a harder one outside. That fear was real. Respecting where it came from will get you further than arguing with it.
Get the Monday email + free printables for your child’s age
The week's best articles for parents raising Black children, plus free printables and book picks. One email, every Monday. Sign up and we will send you our two routine charts plus a free printable made for your child’s age, from a hospital bag checklist to a teen phone agreement.
What has changed is what we know. A review of five decades of research on more than 160,000 children found that the more children are spanked, the more likely they are to defy their parents, along with more aggression and other difficulties. The American Academy of Pediatrics says spanking increases aggression in young children and is ineffective in teaching self-control.
You can honor how Grandma raised you and still decide your child will be raised differently. Both can be true at the same table.
What to Say About Grandparents Spanking: The Exact Words
#1 Before the visit
“Mama, I need your help with something. We don’t spank in our house, and I need that to be true at your house too. You know her better than almost anyone, so I want you on my team for what we do instead.”
#2 When she says, “I spanked you and you turned out fine”
“I did turn out fine, and a lot of that is because of you. I’m just choosing a different tool. The doctors say there are ways that work better, and I want to try them.”
#3 When she says you are too soft
“No spanking doesn’t mean no rules. She still gets consequences. They just look different.”
#4 In the moment, if she reaches for it
“I’ve got this one, Mama.” Then step in, take your child aside and handle it yourself. Talk to Grandma later, in private, never in front of your child.

Give Grandparents Something to Do Instead
Telling an elder what not to do leaves a hole. Fill it. The AAP recommends teaching calmly, setting clear limits and following through with consequences. Write a short list and put it on her fridge:
- Get down to eye level and say the rule once, calmly.
- Redirect toddlers to something else to do with their hands.
- Take a short break together on the couch until everyone is calm.
- Remove the privilege connected to the behavior: no tablet, no dessert, no park today.
- Call me. “If you’re ever stuck, call me and I’ll handle it.”
If Grandma Is Your Child Care
When a grandparent watches your child every day, this conversation is not optional. Make the house rules plain, write them down and check in often. If she keeps spanking after you have asked her to stop, it is fair to change the arrangement or keep visits shorter and with you present until you trust the rule will hold. Protecting your child comes first, even when it is hard.
If It Happens Anyway
- Go to your child first. Comfort them and tell them it was not okay for them to be hit.
- Stay calm with Grandma. “We talked about this. I need you to never do that again.”
- Talk privately later about what she will do next time instead.
- Decide your next step if it happens again, and tell her what it is.
Want to go deeper? Read why grandparents can undo your discipline and how to stop it, five things to know before you spank, and one writer’s story of breaking the cycle of spanking.
Have you had this talk with your parents? What words worked for you? Tell us in the comments, and share this with a parent who needs the script.
One calm talk about grandparents spanking, held early and away from the kids, usually does more than a dozen corrections in the moment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a grandparent spank my child if I say no?
You are the parent, so your house rules should apply when grandparents care for your child. Tell them clearly, in private, that spanking is not allowed and give them what to do instead.
How do I tell my mom not to spank my child?
Talk before the visit, lead with love and what you share, and be direct: “We don’t spank, and I need that to be true at your house too. I want you on my team for what we do instead.”
What should grandparents do instead of spanking?
Get down to eye level and state the rule calmly, redirect a toddler, take a short calm-down break together, remove a related privilege, or call the parent to handle it.
What does the American Academy of Pediatrics say about spanking?
The AAP advises against spanking, saying it increases aggression in young children over time and is ineffective in teaching responsibility and self-control.
What if a grandparent keeps spanking after I ask them to stop?
Comfort your child, restate the rule calmly and privately, and change the arrangement if needed, such as shorter visits with you present, until you trust the rule will be followed.
Photos and some content may be AI generated.
comments +